To say that the funding landscape has changed dramatically over the past few decades is an understatement. But what does the current playing field actually look like, broadly speaking? What’s going on, and what, for example, are the roles of private equity, venture capital, banks, and the NOM?
“If you take risks, you’ll be rewarded,” says Marco de Jong. The NOM’s Investment Manager calls this “investing with guts.” Of course, he knows that many of the companies the NOM finances ultimately don’t make it. “But if we can exit a Catawiki or Polyganics once every ten years, then we’re doing just fine. And in doing so, we’ve also helped a large number of companies find new funding partners.”
This reflects the evolution the organization has undergone over the past 50 years. The NOM has grown from a traditional development agency into a modern, comprehensive development partner. The focus shifted from stimulating and improving employment in the north to a role as an investor in promising (young) companies and a driver of growth, innovation, and sustainable economic development. In other words, from jobs to impact, including funding options for companies in the pre-seed and seed phases, among others.
Extra room
Not only the NOM, but the entire funding landscape has changed drastically over the years. Whereas entrepreneurs in the past mainly relied on traditional bank loans, there is now a wide range of alternative funding sources available.
The 2008 financial crisis marked a major turning point. Banks became more cautious about lending, which created additional opportunities for other players and alternative funding models. As a result, venture capital and private equity have long been viable alternatives to traditional bank funding. Venture capital is for startups and young companies with high growth potential, while private equity is for more mature companies with stable cash flow.
The number of venture capital investors has grown significantly, particularly over the past decade. As a result, there’s plenty of venture capital available for startups and scale-ups. This raises the question: what can NOM still contribute to the funding landscape in this area? “Well, quite a lot,” Marco smiles. “Not least because we’ve noticed that venture capital investors have become more cautious in recent years when it comes to funding high-risk ventures. Meanwhile, we’ve actually shifted our focus back toward companies with a high-risk profile. You just don’t see as many private investors in that space anymore.”
Slowing effect
Thomas Mensink sees that too, of course. He is CEO of startup analyst Golden Egg Check in Enschede and a partner at GEC Capital, Golden Egg Check’s co-investment fund, which invests 5 million euros in venture capital in tech startups and scale-ups. “When it comes to venture capital in the pre-seed and seed investment market, a sort of reset is taking place,” he says. “Many venture capital firms seem to be taking a more measured approach to fundraising and are focusing primarily on their current portfolio companies.”
The cause? That is difficult to say, according to Thomas. I sometimes compare it to a traffic jam. Somewhere it gets stuck and everyone starts braking. We are in the middle of that now. There is just a slowing down effect. If you are not completely sure that a good follow-on investor is ready, you may want to keep more money in reserve to take a company to the next stage. Investors then become more critical and focus more on safe deals and less on the hidden gems with a higher risk profile.'
However, there is no question of any delay at GEC Capital itself. Launched in 2022, the co-investment fund has already made some 24 investments. 'We participate in a small part in a big round and help a startup find a lead investor,' Thomas says of the investment strategy. 'Unlike most other investors, we are relatively hands-off and focus mainly on access to capital. That allows us to build a large portfolio. And that's exactly what you want when you invest in startups.'
Innovation loan
What about banks? What is their role in today’s funding landscape? What can they do for startups, for example? “Usually not very much,” Thomas believes. “Because there’s usually no steady revenue stream, collateral, or proven track record, it’s virtually impossible for startups to successfully approach a bank. The exception is Rabobank, which supports startups with an Innovation Loan. As far as I know, it’s the only bank that says: we accept that it doesn’t always work out, but when it does, we build a long-term relationship with the startup. I think that’s a valuable addition to the ecosystem.”
Indeed, the Rabo Innovation Loan is a subordinated loan to finance innovative ideas. A condition is that the company contributes to digitalization or making society more sustainable. 'We are a meaningful bank and want to remain so,' stresses Renate Venema-Zomer, director of Rabobank Heerenveen-Zuidoost Friesland. 'Our cooperative structure allows us to distinguish ourselves emphatically from other banks. For example, Rabobank has no shareholders for whom profit maximization is the primary goal. In fact, in order to make an impact, we give part of the profit back to society.'
Staggered funding
Renate explains that Rabobank's focus is increasingly on sustainability and social transition. Sustainability has really become a license to operate. For example, the bank is actively committed to supporting companies in their transition to sustainable business models. 'Of course there are rules and regulations,' she explains. 'And yes, as a bank we have to maintain larger buffers. But if you look at our financial ratios, we exceed them. That's why I want to emphasize that as a bank we want to finance and help companies grow.
Rabobank is increasingly partnering closely with other financial institutions to finance businesses. This is all about accelerating transitions and innovations. “As a bank, we obviously can’t do that on our own,” says Renate. “To help businesses and society move forward, we sometimes also need capital from a venture capitalist, crowdfunding, a private equity firm, or an organization like NOM. This is called ‘stacked funding’—the combination of different forms of funding. We simply need each other more than ever.”
Profitable story
Greater and more targeted collaboration, along with a growing focus on ESG criteria (Environmental, Social & Governance), is one of the aspects that characterizes today’s funding landscape. At NOM, for example, this is also reflected in the funding of growth or acquisitions. For instance, since 2018, investments have been made in the Growth Fund of Berk Partners, a private equity investor that focuses on existing, fast-growing Dutch SMEs, primarily in the food industry, innovative manufacturing, and healthcare suppliers.
'You have various private equity parties taking over ailing companies in which banks have no confidence,' says fund manager Willem Kamps of Berk Partners. 'Under the motto: on the edge of the abyss grow the most beautiful flowers. We don't do that. We only provide venture capital to established companies with a profitable story, good management and well-founded growth plans. With such companies you often also see that banks are quite willing to co-finance. They also know that good entrepreneurs, and fortunately there are many of them in the Netherlands, make the right choices even under difficult circumstances.'
Impact investor
Berk Partners was founded in 1992 and grew out of the private investment firm of the late Ben Pon, one of the former shareholders of Pon Holdings. Essentially, says Willem, the investment strategy has remained virtually unchanged since then. “We have traditionally focused on the same segments and the same type of companies. The food sector, the manufacturing industry, and healthcare suppliers are segments we know inside and out and which, in our view, are also somewhat less sensitive to economic cycles. Certainly, ESG criteria are becoming increasingly important. From a societal perspective, but also for the investors who participate in our fund. But our goal has always been to return companies after five years in a more sustainable state than when we first invested. Furthermore, the expectation is that selling a company with an ESG profile will result in a significantly better price in a few years’ time.”
Attention to ESG criteria is a must for the funds and companies in which NOM invests. Logical, if you are working towards a sustainable, healthier and smarter economy in the Northern Netherlands. But at the same time, the sustainability and ethical impact of companies are becoming increasingly prominent for financiers. 'The obligation to report on ESG is still a bit further in the future,' Marco de Jong explains. 'But we want to be well ahead of that, partly through our cooperation with an investor like Berk Partners. We have to if we want to be an impact investor like NOM.'